Why Did so Many Christians Support American Slavery?

Throughout the church’s existence, there have been times when it was on the right side of history. Other times, it has been on the wrong side of history. And in other cases, it was on both sides, simultaneously. This was certainly the case in America when it came to the institution of chattel slavery.

Prior to and all throughout the American Civil War, devout Christians stood on either side of the abolition movement. They were all reading the same Bible, but somehow they were coming to drastically different conclusions when it came to the American system of slavery. As a result, America was one of the last western nations to abolish it, decades after much of Europe—and even British colonies around the world.

In this episode, we explore the history of the abolitionist movement through a theological lens. What biblical arguments were preachers and theologians making for (and against) abolition at the time? And why did it take America’s bloodiest war to settle the question once and for all?


READ: Colorblindness and the Persistence of White Supremacist Theology
READ: 4 Ways Colorblind Theology Falls Short


The Civil War as a Theological Crisis” by Mark Noll

Subscribe On Apple Podcasts | Follow On Spotify

Latest Episodes

Ecumenism: How United Should the Global Church Be?
Are Demons Making Us Sick?
What's the Deal With Horoscopes?
5 Hot Takes on the 10 Commandments
Christian Thoughts on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)
Will Our Pets Be in Heaven? (And Other Questions)
Poverty, Welfare, and 'Rich Men North of Richmond'
Why Are Christians Obsessed With the Enneagram? (And Should We Stop?)
Emmett Till, Florida Slavery Curriculum, and the Importance of History to Faith
Church as a Business?
‘Sound of Freedom,’ Child Sex Trafficking, Conspiracy Theories, and How To Be Helpful
The Long History Behind Evangelical Opposition to Social Justice
Do Pastors Have To Go to Seminary?
Is There a Multiverse (And Should Christians Even Care)?
When Culture War Conversations Jump the Shark
Why Would Anyone Plant a Church?
Public Accountability or Failure Porn? Assessing the Uptick in Christian ‘Rise and Fall’ Content
Why Did so Many Christians Support American Slavery?
Timothy Keller and the Legacy of Winsomeness
Should We Send Our Kids to Private Christian Schools?
What Is A Jezebel Spirit?
How Much Should Christians Care About the Age of the Earth?
What Is a Gospel Issue?
Should Christians Use Other People's Preferred Pronouns?
The Debate Surrounding Biblical Inerrancy

Explore More Episodes