Was the SBC Wrong To Kick out Saddleback?

On Tuesday, February 21, the Southern Baptist Convention Executive Committee announced that Saddleback Church was no longer “in friendly cooperation” with the denomination and had been disfellowshipped.

Famously founded by Rick Warren, Saddleback had long been the largest church in the SBC. Nevertheless, they were removed from the denomination because they have ordained women on their staff to the title of “pastor,” one of whom is in the regular weekend service preaching rotation.

Was the SBC within their rights, or are they out of pocket on this one?

In this episode, we discuss the story that led up to Saddleback’s ousting from the SBC, the theological questions involved, as well as how this news has been received, particularly in light of how the SBC has been slow to move on reform in light of sexual abuse scandals.


READ: Reconciling the Opposing Views on Women in Church Leadership
READ: 4 Ways Complementarian Church Leaders Can Dignify Women
READ: Should Women Really ‘Keep Silent’ in Church? Understanding 1 Corinthians 14:34-35
READ: 3 Things Christians Can (and Must) Do for Sexual Abuse Survivors
READ: The Shared Value of Man and Woman
READ: Maintaining Hope in the Church in Light of Sexual Abuse Scandals
READ: ‘Nobody’s Perfect’ Is a Poor Response to Church Scandals

LISTEN: Sewing, Knitting, Etc. (Podcast Episode)


READ: Saddleback Church Kicked out of SBC Over Female Pastors
READ: Saddleback’s Status as an SBC Church in Doubt As Mohler, Ascol, Others Push for Disfellowship on the Convention Floor

Subscribe On Apple Podcasts | Follow On Spotify

Latest Episodes

The Debate Surrounding Biblical Inerrancy
Are ChatGPT and AI Going To Take Over the World?
Sex as an Icon for Salvation?
Was the SBC Wrong To Kick out Saddleback?
The Asbury Revival: Are We Seeing a Move of God?
The Christian History of Valentine's Day
A Fresh Look at Old Liturgy
The One Thing All Christians Agree On
Is Anxiety 'Temporary Atheism'?
Things in History the Church Got Right
Why Do So Many Christians Believe in QAnon?
Should Slave-Owning Theologians Get Statues Celebrating Their Memory?
Was Jesus Trans?
How Your Nativity Decorations Are Biblically Inaccurate
Is Biblical Counseling the Answer to America's Mental Health Crisis?
Does the Bible Command Christians To Tithe?
Should We Declare 'Pandemic Amnesty'?
Let's Talk About Kanye
Sad and Angry Songs in the Bible
Should We Baptize Our Babies?
The Problem of Evil
What Does the Bible Say About Angels?
Rapture Anxiety
How Technology Shapes our Ethics and Vice Versa
Evangelism in a Pluralistic Nation

Explore More Episodes